LITTLE ROCK — The Arkansas Court of Appeals on Wednesday upheld a $3 million jury verdict against the Arkansas State Highway Commission in a long-running eminent domain dispute over land near Interstate 40 in Conway.
The ruling affirms a June 2024 Faulkner County Circuit Court judgment in favor of William Lewis and Cody Lewis, co-trustees of the William Major Lewis Trust. The commission condemned 1.62 acres of the trust’s property in August 2015 to widen Dave Ward Drive and add roundabouts. The taking eliminated the property’s direct access to the road.
The Highway Commission initially deposited $417,825 as its estimate of just compensation. The Lewises’ appraiser valued the loss at about $3.89 million. A Faulkner County jury awarded $3 million. Circuit Judge Susan K. Weaver added 8 percent interest compounded annually from the 2015 taking date, along with roughly $123,000 in attorney’s fees and costs.
The Lewises testified that restoring functional access required building new roads and roundabouts that cost $4 million to $4.5 million and used about seven acres of their remaining land. The Court of Appeals, in an opinion by Judge Mike Murphy, found the evidence of those costs was properly admitted as relevant to the property’s diminished market value.
“The roads the Lewises built were the means of restoring functional access to the part of the property fronting the highway,” the court stated. The panel also held that the $3 million verdict was supported by substantial evidence and fell between the competing appraisals. It rejected the commission’s challenges to the interest rate and the timing of the fee request.
Chief Judge Rita W. Klappenbach and Judges Raymond R. Abramson, Bart F. Virden and Kenneth S. Hixson joined the majority. Judge Brandon J. Harrison dissented. The case is Arkansas State Highway Commission v. Lewis, 2026 Ark. App. 517.
The dispute took nearly nine years to reach trial. The Court of Appeals decision leaves the judgment intact.

